| # | Title | Artist | Rating | Length |
|---|
| A1 | Happy Day in Hell | Erika Henningsen, Stephanie Beatriz, Sam Haft, Mick Lauer, Keith David, Blake Roman & Andrew Underberg | 4 | 2:58 |
| A2 | Hell Is Forever | Andrew Underberg, Sam Haft, Alex Brightman & Erika Henningsen | 5 | 2:21 |
| A3 | Stayed Gone | Andrew Underberg, Sam Haft, Christian Borle, Amir Talai & Joel Perez | 4 | 3:00 |
| A4 | It Starts With Sorry | Andrew Underberg, Sam Haft, Alex Brightman, Erika Henningsen, Stephanie Beatriz & Blake Roman | 4 | 1:30 |
| A5 | Respectless | Andrew Underberg, Sam Haft, Daphne Rubin‐Vega, Lilli Cooper & James Monroe Iglehart | 5 | 1:36 |
| A6 | Whatever It Takes | Andrew Underberg, Sam Haft, Daphne Rubin‐Vega, Stephanie Beatriz & James Monroe Iglehart | 4 | 2:57 |
| A7 | Poison | Blake Roman, Sam Haft & Andrew Underberg | 4 | 2:08 |
| A8 | Loser, Baby | Andrew Underberg, Sam Haft, Keith David & Blake Roman | 4 | 2:55 |
| B9 | Hell’s Greatest Dad | Andrew Underberg, Sam Haft, Jeremy Jordan, Amir Talai, Erika Henningsen & Kimiko Glenn | 4 | 2:14 |
| B10 | More Than Anything | Andrew Underberg, Sam Haft, Jeremy Jordan & Erika Henningsen | 4 | 3:13 |
| B11 | Welcome to Heaven | Andrew Underberg, Sam Haft, Darren Criss, Shoba Narayan & Patina Miller | 4 | 1:01 |
| B12 | You Didn’t Know | Andrew Underberg, Sam Haft, Erika Henningsen, Shoba Narayan, Patina Miller, Jessica Vosk & Stephanie Beatriz | 5 | 3:09 |
| B13 | Out for Love | Andrew Underberg, Sam Haft & Daphne Rubin‐Vega | 4 | 1:30 |
| B14 | Ready for This | Andrew Underberg, Sam Haft, Erika Henningsen, Leslie Kritzer, Amir Talai, Kimiko Glenn, Alex Brightman & Blake Roman | 4 | 3:30 |
| B15 | More Than Anything (reprise) | Andrew Underberg, Sam Haft, Erika Henningsen & Stephanie Beatriz | 5 | 1:00 |
| B16 | Finale | Andrew Underberg, Sam Haft, Erika Henningsen, Jeremy Jordan, Amir Talai, Stephanie Beatriz, Blake Roman, Keith David, Christian Borle, Joel Perez, Kimiko Glenn & Krystina Alabado | 5 | 3:51 |