| # | Title | Artist | Rating | Length |
|---|
| 1 | Fly Me to the Moon (In Other Words) | Johnny Mathis | | 3:55 |
| 2 | When Sunny Gets Blue | Johnny Mathis with Ray Conniff and His Orchestra | | 2:42 |
| 3 | Chances Are | Johnny Mathis | | 3:03 |
| 4 | Wonderful! Wonderful! | Johnny Mathis with Ray Conniff, His Orchestra & Chorus | | 2:49 |
| 5 | It's Not for Me to Say | Johnny Mathis | | 3:05 |
| 6 | No Love (But Your Love) | Johnny Mathis | | 2:19 |
| 7 | The Twelfth of Never | Johnny Mathis | | 2:27 |
| 8 | Wild Is the Wind- orchestra:
- Ray Ellis and His Orchestra
- recording of:
- Wild Is the Wind
- lyricist:
- Ned Washington
- composer:
- Dimitri Tiomkin
- publisher:
- BMG Music Publishing Ltd., Carlin Music Corporation, Shapiro, Bernstein & Co., Inc., Universal Music Publishing MGB Ltd., Anne‐Rachel Music Corp. (in 1957, in 1985), Catharine Hinen Music (in 1957, in 1985), Chappell & Co., Inc. (in 1957), Largo Music Inc. (in 1957, in 1985) and Patti Washington Music (in 1957, in 1985)
- part of:
- The 30th Academy Award for Best Original Song (number: 2)
| Johnny Mathis with Ray Ellis and His Orchestra | | 2:26 |
| 9 | Teacher, Teacher | Johnny Mathis | | 2:40 |
| 10 | A Certain Smile | Johnny Mathis | 3 | 2:48 |
| 11 | Misty- producer:
- Al Ham and Mitch Miller
- vocals:
- Johnny Mathis (in 1959)
- conductor:
- Glenn Osser (in 1959)
- arranger:
- Glenn Osser
- recording of:
- Misty
- lyricist:
- Johnny Burke
- composer:
- Erroll Garner
- publisher:
- BMG Songs, Inc., Marke Music Publishing Co., Inc., My Dad’s Songs, Inc., Octave Music Publishing Corp., Pocketful of Dreams Music, Reganesque Music Company, Spirit Two Music Inc., The Songwriters Guild, Vernon Music Inc., Warner/Chappell Music Ltd. and WB Music Corp.
- is based on:
- Misty
| Johnny Mathis | | 3:36 |
| 12 | You Are Beautiful | Johnny Mathis | | 3:08 |
| 13 | Maria | Johnny Mathis | | 3:47 |
| 14 | My Funny Valentine- guitar:
- Al Caiola and Tony Mottola
- vocals:
- Johnny Mathis
- recording of:
- My Funny Valentine
- lyricist:
- Lorenz Hart (in 1937)
- composer:
- Richard Rodgers (in 1937)
- publisher:
- Chappell & Co., Inc. , Touch Music Publishing Pte Ltd., Warner Chappell Music Ltd. , Warner/Chappell and Williamson Music Company
- sub-publisher:
- Warner/Chappell Music, Hong Kong Limited , シンコーミュージック・エンタテイメント , ヤマハミュージックエンタテインメントホールディングス and ワーナー・チャペル音楽出版 Synch事業部
- included in:
- The Real Book
- part of:
- Babes in Arms
- part of:
- Waiting to Exhale
- cover recording of:
- My Funny Valentine
- lyricist:
- Lorenz Hart (in 1937)
- composer:
- Richard Rodgers (in 1937)
- publisher:
- Chappell & Co., Inc. , Touch Music Publishing Pte Ltd., Warner Chappell Music Ltd. , Warner/Chappell and Williamson Music Company
- sub-publisher:
- Warner/Chappell Music, Hong Kong Limited , シンコーミュージック・エンタテイメント , ヤマハミュージックエンタテインメントホールディングス and ワーナー・チャペル音楽出版 Synch事業部
- included in:
- The Real Book
- part of:
- Babes in Arms
- part of:
- Waiting to Exhale
| Johnny Mathis | | 3:36 |
| 15 | Small World | Johnny Mathis | | 3:18 |
| 16 | The Best of Everything | Johnny Mathis | | 2:45 |
| 17 | When I Fall in Love | Johnny Mathis | | 4:30 |
| 18 | Dancing on the Ceiling | Johnny Mathis | | 3:56 |