| # | Title | Artist | Rating | Length |
|---|
| 1 | Heavenly | Johnny Mathis | | 3:20 |
| 2 | Hello, Young Lovers | Johnny Mathis | | 4:16 |
| 3 | A Lovely Way to Spend an Evening | Johnny Mathis | | 4:02 |
| 4 | A Ride on a Rainbow | Johnny Mathis | | 4:08 |
| 5 | More Than You Know | Johnny Mathis | | 4:14 |
| 6 | Something I Dreamed Last Night | Johnny Mathis | | 4:30 |
| 7 | Misty- producer:
- Al Ham and Mitch Miller
- vocals:
- Johnny Mathis (in 1959)
- conductor:
- Glenn Osser (in 1959)
- arranger:
- Glenn Osser
- recording of:
- Misty
- lyricist:
- Johnny Burke
- composer:
- Erroll Garner
- publisher:
- BMG Songs, Inc., Marke Music Publishing Co., Inc., My Dad’s Songs, Inc., Octave Music Publishing Corp., Pocketful of Dreams Music, Reganesque Music Company, Spirit Two Music Inc., The Songwriters Guild, Vernon Music Inc., Warner/Chappell Music Ltd. and WB Music Corp.
- is based on:
- Misty
| Johnny Mathis | | 3:37 |
| 8 | Stranger in Paradise- producer:
- Al Ham and Mitch Miller
- vocals:
- Johnny Mathis (in 1959)
- conductor:
- Glenn Osser (in 1959)
- arranger:
- Glenn Osser
- cover recording of:
- Stranger in Paradise (in 1959)
- lyricist:
- George Forrest and Robert Wright
- composer:
- Alexander Borodin , George Forrest and Robert Wright
- publisher:
- Scheffel Music Corp, Warner Chappell Music Ltd. , Warner/Chappell and Frank Music Co. Ltd. (from 1953 to present)
- is based on:
- Polovtsian Dances no. 17, “Polovtsian Dance with Chorus”: II. Gliding Dance of the Maidens: Andantino, 4/4, A major
- part of:
- Kismet
- recording of:
- Stranger in Paradise
- lyricist:
- George Forrest and Robert Wright
- composer:
- Alexander Borodin , George Forrest and Robert Wright
- publisher:
- Scheffel Music Corp, Warner Chappell Music Ltd. , Warner/Chappell and Frank Music Co. Ltd. (from 1953 to present)
- is based on:
- Polovtsian Dances no. 17, “Polovtsian Dance with Chorus”: II. Gliding Dance of the Maidens: Andantino, 4/4, A major
- part of:
- Kismet
| Johnny Mathis & orchestra under the direction of Glenn Osser | | 4:04 |
| 9 | Moonlight Becomes You | Johnny Mathis | | 4:04 |
| 10 | They Say It’s Wonderful (from “Annie Get Your Gun”) | Johnny Mathis & orchestra under the direction of Glenn Osser | | 3:31 |
| 11 | I’ll Be Easy to Find | Johnny Mathis | | 4:02 |
| 12 | That’s All | Johnny Mathis | | 3:51 |